Tullulah’s, Bay Shore
Tullulah’s Grilled Cheese. Image: Justin Bernard
Pay homage to the grilled cheese sandwich at Tullulah’s in Bay Shore. Their grilled cheese comes with brie, apple cider caramelized onions and poached apples on whole grain bread and with the option to add pork belly.
Post Office Café, Babylon
Bacon makes everything better. This the chefs at Babylon’s Post Office Cafe must know, as both their grilled cheese sandwiches come with bacon. Order the Classic Grilled Cheese, which comes with American cheese, applewood bacon and tomato. For those that love goat cheese, the North Fork Grilled Cheese comes with rocket arugula, goat cheese, roasted tomatoes and applewood bacon on seven grain rustic bread.
C’est Cheese, Port Jefferson
The scamorza grilled cheese. Image: C’est Cheese
Seven different grilled cheese sandwiches mean there is something for every cheese lover’s taste at Port Jefferson’s C’est Cheese. Fancy some brie, apple and honey? Order the Parisian. Go a bit more rustic with smoked mozzarella, prosciutto di parma and sundried tomato pesto on The Scamorza Grilled Cheese or try The Capra Griller with fresh goat cheese, fig preserve and watercress on wheat. Plus, there’s always The Classic, which comes with lots of melted cheddar and nothing else. A whole month is needed to sample them all.