Mix things up this season with a frozen take on your favorite fall flavors. Some of the best Long Island ice cream shops are serving cold and creamy varieties that will have anyone excited for the cooler days ahead.
Related Content: 2017 Long Island Fall Festivals Not to Miss
Pumpkin
Old Fashioned Ice Cream, West Babylon
image: facebook.com/stoehrersoldfashionedicecream
When it’s too warm to sip a piping hot pumpkin spice latte, scream for creamy pumpkin ice cream. As a play on a fall favorite, Old Fashioned Ice Cream is also making pumpkin pies filled with its pumpkin ice cream and covered in caramel topping. Address: 1025 Straight Path | Phone: 631-669-3020 Click to go
The Perfect Apple Pie
Kilwins, Patchogue, Babylon, Port Jefferson and Huntington
Scattered throughout the Island, Kilwin’s ice cream is some of the best around. Using a tasty original recipe, Kilwins is serving a flavor called the perfect apple pie and let’s just say it’s not a euphemism. The treat includes vanilla ice cream with caramel, baked apples, pie crust pieces and a hint of cinnamon. Patchogue: Address: 74 East Main Street | Phone: 631-627-8584 Babylon: Address: 130 Deer Park Avenue | Phone: 631-482-8551 Port Jefferson: Address: 109D Main Street | Phone: 631-509-6555 Huntington: Address: 293 Main Street | Phone: 631-271-4200 Click to go
Salted Caramel
Ice Cream Cottage, Mastic
Although it’s a popular flavor year-round, caramel moves up a notch on the food chain each fall as the caramel apple makes its way back into our stomachs. Lucky for Long Islanders, the Ice Cream Cottage serves it all year round. Address: 1590 Montauk Highway | Phone: 631-398-3580 Click to go
Oatmeal Cookie
Frozen Cow Ices and Cream, Lido Beach
image: facebook.com/frozencowicesandcream
A frozen take on a classic cookie, Frozen Cow Ices and Cream offers customers a delicious autumn blend. This oatmeal cookie ice cream with a rich cinnamon flavor is sure to put anyone in the fall spirit. Address: 300 Lido Boulevard | Phone: 516-665-3997 Click to go
Peach
Hicksville Sweet Shop, Hicksville
National Peach Month (August) may be over, but peach cobbler never goes out of style. Get the Thanksgiving favorite in ice cream form at this Nassau sweet shop, which is serving up peach cobbler and peach ice cream. Address: 75 Broadway | Phone: 516-931-0130 Click to go
Pumkin/Pumpkin Patch
Five Pennies Creamery, Rockville Centre
image: facebook.com/fivepenniescreamery
Pumpkins are one of the most popular fall symbols, seeping their way in everything from lattes to pie. Besides a pumpkin flavored ice cream, Five Pennies Creamery is adding a twist called the pumpkin patch, pumpkin ice cream with Oreo topping. Address: 11 N Park Avenue | Phone: 516-608-4344 Click to go